“Life in Pieces” (CBS) pilot preview: The stories of a not so Modern Family

LIFEIN

Created and procuded by Justin Adler (Better Off Ted, Less Than Perfect). Executive Produced and directed by Jason Winer (Modern Family, The Crazy Ones). Co-produced by Aaron Kaplan (The Neighbors, Friends With Better Lives). For CBS, 20th Century FOX Television, Kapital Entertainment & Smalldog Picture Co. 36 pages.

Description: One family is told through the separate stories of its different family members, from feshly divorced Matt and his new girlfriend Colleen to young parents Greg & Jen, helped by long married couple with teenage kids Tim & Heather and Grandpa John & Grandma Joan…

With Thomas Sadoski (The Newsroom, The Slap US), Betsy Brandt (Breaking Bad, Parenthood, The Michael J. Fox Show), Colin Hanks (Roswell, Dexter, Fargo), Dianne Wiest (In Treatment, Law & Order), James Brolin (Pensacola, Hotel), Zoe Lister Jones (Whitney, Friends With Better Lives), Angelique Cabral (Enlisted), Dan Bakkedahl

rate rate rate rate

One Big Family. Fourt short stories. Every Week“. That’s the promise made by writer Justin Adler at the very beginning of the script, right after the title. He wants to make it pretty clear: this family comedy won’t be like any other. Except he forgot just one tiny thing: Modern Family is already on the air for 6 years! And if every little story of the Pritchett/Dunphy family is not totally separated from each other by commercial breaks as it is the case here, moving forward, Life In Pieces will undoubtedly have to mix the stories a little, inviting one or two characters into the short stories of the others, and then we’ll have something looking an awful lot like ABC hit show! Plus, they are using the same trick as in Modern Family‘s pilot: the fact that the characters are all part of the same family is only revealed at the end. Of course, you have to be really dumb not to understand it before (if you haven’t read it somewhere yet) ! That being said, Life In Pieces‘ script is good. It’s just sad the only so called original thing here is the concept (and choosing not very funny actors to play funny characters – look at their faces in the picture)…

Sorry to break it  to you like that but Life In Pieces is not very diversity-friendly! It’s an all-white, quite rich family. In the script, the character of Jen is said to be asian. CBS chose Zoe Lister-Jones to play her. And she’s not asian. But she’s hilarious, which is better. But it was the only touch of exoticism! I don’t want to start any debate about this whole diversity thing right now, but I think the show would have been much more modern than Modern Family is with an all-black or all-latino or all-asian or all-mixed cast.There is no trace of homosexuality either. A lesbian couple would have been nice. So we have the same set of characters that we are used to. And it feels outdated.

In the first segment (not the best one), we meet a freshly divorced man (Thomas Sadoski) at his first date with his new (an younger) potential girlfriend. It gets complicated when he meets her very annoying ex-boyfriend who still lives with her. I would have prefered a freshly divorced woman at her first date with her new (AND YOUNGER) potential boyfriend (or girlfriend !) for a change. Anyway. Then we have the young married couple who are expecting their first child. It’s the best segment (tied with the last one). Not because it feels new, but because the lines are really bold and funny as hell. Jen is about to give birth and all she is scared of is pooping during the delivery. And then there’s a huge problem regarding her vagina. I laughed hard. Third segment is about an older couple (Betsy Brandt…), married for a longtime, visiting colleges for and with their teenage boy. The thing is he gets drunk at night and everything goes out of control. It’s more sweet than funny to be honest. But it’s OK. Last segment reunites the whole family for a very special occasion: the patriarch’s funeral… except he’s not dead! He just wanted to hear a lot of nice things about him while alive. The idea is just great and the lines are once again hilarious. And we’re starting to like them.

I recognize I may be a little hard on this one. Life In Pieces is an uneven but quite good script… but for a show launched 6 years ago, before Modern Family arrives. CBS has definitely found something that looks like a hit, with a terrific cast, but in my opinion, they missed an opportunity to be relevant about diversity. It was the perfect vehicle for it. And CBS is not the right place for this single-camera comedy, by the way. We’ll see if the network goes for it or smashes it to pieces…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *